The Ultimate List of Supernatural TV Shows You Need to Watch
Are you ready to dive into a world where the impossible becomes reality? The supernatural genre has always captivated us, offering eerie mysteries, ghostly encounters, and magical realms that make our imaginations run wild. Whether you’re a long-time fan or new to the genre, there’s something thrilling about watching characters navigate the unknown, battle spirits, and uncover ancient secrets.
In today’s post, we’re exploring ten of the best supernatural TV shows to watch that have left a mark on viewers. While some of these series have sadly been cancelled, they still offer a binge-worthy experience filled with chills, excitement, and unforgettable stories. So grab your favourite snack, settle in, and let’s get started!
Top Supernatural TV Shows You Must Watch
The supernatural genre offers a diverse range of TV shows, each bringing something unique to the table. From comedy-horror hybrids to dark, atmospheric dramas, these series will keep you on the edge of your seat.
Truth Seekers
First up is “Truth Seekers“—a series that masterfully blends comedy with supernatural horror. Starring Nick Frost and Simon Pegg, this show follows a group of part-time paranormal investigators in the UK. Gus, the main character, is a broadband installer by day and ghost hunter by night, leading his ragtag team through increasingly strange and dangerous hauntings. Despite its short run of only eight episodes, Truth Seekers manages to balance genuine scares with quintessential British humour. Though it was unfortunately cancelled after just one season, it remains a must-watch for fans of both comedy and the supernatural.
Dead Boy Detectives
Next, we have “Dead Boy Detectives“, a series that brings Neil Gaiman’s beloved comic characters to life. This adaptation follows two deceased teenagers who choose to stay on Earth and solve supernatural mysteries rather than move on to the afterlife. What makes this show particularly intriguing is its connection to The Sandman universe, offering a unique perspective on death and the afterlife through the eyes of eternally young detectives. The show’s ongoing status means viewers can look forward to exploring more of Neil Gaiman’s richly imaginative world.
Lockwood & Co.
Lockwood & Co. takes us to an alternative London where ghost-hunting agencies employ gifted young people to combat a plague of spirits. Based on Jonathan Stroud’s young adult book series, this Netflix show impresses with its world-building and visual effects, especially in its portrayal of ghosts—ranging from eerily beautiful to downright terrifying. The series centres on the bonds between its young protagonists as much as their ghost-hunting adventures. Although Lockwood & Co. was cancelled after one season, a passionate fanbase is campaigning for its return. You can join the movement at Save Lockwood & Co. on YouTube.
The Irregulars
For a supernatural twist on classic literature, “The Irregulars“ offers a dark reimagining of the Sherlock Holmes universe. Set in Victorian London, this series follows a group of street kids employed by Dr Watson to solve increasingly bizarre and otherworldly crimes. The show stands out for focusing on the young protagonists rather than Holmes himself, providing a fresh perspective on a well-known story. Despite its intriguing premise, The Irregulars was unfortunately cancelled after one season, but it remains a captivating watch that offers a complete and engaging story arc.
Underrated Supernatural TV Shows You Shouldn’t Miss
These shows might not have received the attention they deserve, but they are gems in the supernatural genre.
Warrior Nun
Warrior Nun burst onto Netflix with a premise as wild as its title suggests. Based on the comic book Warrior Nun Areala, the series explores themes of faith, free will, and the nature of good and evil, all wrapped up in impressive fight choreography and special effects. What adds an extra layer of allure to Warrior Nun is its stunning filming locations across Spain’s Iberian Peninsula, an area close to my neck of the woods in the western Algarve. The series showcases the breathtaking beauty of the region, with many scenes shot in iconic Spanish locales such as Málaga, Ronda, Antequera, Almodóvar del Río, and the historic city of Sevilla.
The natural landscapes and architectural marvels featured in the show provide a visually stunning backdrop that enhances the storytelling. From the rolling hills and vibrant streets of Málaga to the majestic Almodóvar del Río Castle, which serves as a key location, the series immerses viewers in the rich cultural and historical tapestry of southern Spain. The beauty of the Iberian Peninsula is on full display, making it not just a treat for fans of supernatural action, but also for those who appreciate captivating scenery.
For viewers who are drawn to both natural and architectural beauty, Warrior Nun offers more than just an engaging narrative—it’s a visual journey through some of the most picturesque and historically rich locations in Spain. Although Warrior Nun faced cancellation, its breathtaking setting and compelling story continue to capture the imaginations of fans worldwide, making it a series well worth exploring.
Surreal Estate
Surreal Estate offers a refreshing take on the haunted house genre, following a real estate team that specializes in selling properties with supernatural challenges. Starring Tim Rozon and Sarah Levy, this Canadian series combines spooky elements with humour and heart, making it a unique addition to the supernatural genre. The show was initially cancelled after its first season, much to the disappointment of its fans. However, earlier this year, it was announced that Surreal Estate will be returning for another season—exciting news for those who loved its innovative premise. With the promise of more ghostly adventures on the horizon, now is the perfect time to catch up on the first season and prepare for what’s next! I for one am super excited!
Supernatural TV Shows with Rich Storylines
These series excel in storytelling, offering deep lore and intricate plots that keep viewers hooked.
Nancy Drew
The 2019 reimagining of “Nancy Drew“ takes the beloved teen detective and plunges her into a world of ghosts and ancient curses. This CW series successfully updates Nancy Drew for a contemporary audience while maintaining the mystery-solving essence that has made her an enduring character. The show’s commitment to supernatural elements and its blend of spooky atmosphere with young adult drama makes it appealing to both long-time fans and newcomers. After four successful seasons, the series concluded its run, offering a satisfying journey through the supernatural.
The Nevers
The Nevers presents a unique blend of a Victorian-era setting, supernatural abilities, and steampunk aesthetics. Created by Joss Whedon for HBO, the series follows a group of people—mostly women—who suddenly manifest extraordinary abilities. The show’s intricate plot and high production values make it a visual and intellectual treat. Although The Nevers was cancelled, its rich world-building and thematic depth offer a compelling take on period dramas and superhero narratives alike.
A Discovery of Witches
For those who prefer their supernatural tales with a side of romance, “A Discovery of Witches“ delivers beautifully. Based on Deborah Harkness’s All Souls trilogy, the series follows Diana Bishop, a historian and reluctant witch, as she becomes entangled with Matthew Clairmont, a centuries-old vampire. The show’s thoughtful exploration of witch, vampire, and daemon mythology is intricately woven with the rich tapestry of history, as the protagonists journey back in time to some of the most fascinating periods. This time-travel element not only deepens the narrative but also makes the series even more visually appealing.
As Diana and Matthew traverse through different eras, viewers are treated to lavish historical settings that are as captivating as the story itself. The show takes full advantage of its historical backdrop, showcasing stunning locations that bring the past to life with remarkable authenticity. From the atmospheric streets of Elizabethan London to the grandeur of French chateaux, the series immerses viewers in the period’s opulence and the intrigue of bygone eras.
The combination of supernatural romance, rich historical settings, and breathtaking cinematography makes A Discovery of Witches a visual feast and a compelling supernatural drama. The series concluded after three seasons, successfully adapting the trilogy to the screen and leaving a lasting impression on viewers with its beautifully crafted blend of magic, history, and romance.
Mayfair Witches
Rounding out our list is “Mayfair Witches“, based on Anne Rice’s Lives of the Mayfair Witches novels. Set in the atmospheric backdrop of New Orleans, the series follows Dr. Rowan Fielding, a neurosurgeon who discovers she is the heir to a family of witches. The show’s Southern Gothic charm and its connections to the wider Anne Rice universe, including potential crossovers with Interview with the Vampire, add layers of intrigue. As the series continues, it delves deeper into the dark legacy of witchcraft, making it a spine-chilling yet thought-provoking watch.
Why Supernatural TV Shows Are Worth Watching
The supernatural genre is more than just ghosts and ghouls; it’s a window into our deepest fears and greatest curiosities. These TV shows provide an escape from the mundane, allowing us to explore worlds where the laws of reality bend, and anything is possible. Whether it’s through the lens of horror, mystery, or fantasy, supernatural shows challenge our perceptions and keep us questioning what lies beyond the known world.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a supernatural TV show engaging?
A supernatural TV show becomes engaging when it blends strong characters, compelling storylines, and an immersive atmosphere. The element of the unknown, combined with relatable human emotions, makes these shows intriguing and suspenseful.
Why do some best supernatural TV shows to watch get cancelled?
There are several reasons why supernatural TV shows get cancelled, ranging from low viewership ratings to high production costs. Despite their creativity, some shows struggle to maintain an audience or compete with other content.
Are there any ongoing supernatural TV shows worth watching?
Yes, Dead Boy Detectives and Mayfair Witches are ongoing and continue to explore rich supernatural narratives. These shows have garnered attention for their unique takes on the genre and are worth adding to your watchlist.
Can I still watch cancelled supernatural TV shows?
Absolutely! Many cancelled supernatural TV shows are available on streaming platforms like Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime. Despite their early endings, these shows often provide complete and satisfying story arcs.
What supernatural TV show is best for beginners?
For beginners, A Discovery of Witches is an excellent choice. Its mix of romance, mythology, and supernatural intrigue makes it accessible and engaging for newcomers to the genre.
Is there hope for the return of cancelled supernatural TV shows?
In some cases, fan campaigns and petitions have successfully revived cancelled shows, as seen with Surreal Estate. While it’s not always guaranteed, there’s always hope for a return if enough viewers express their interest.
Conclusion
While it’s disappointing that some of these fantastic shows were cancelled prematurely, each series offers a unique and captivating experience. Whether a show ran for multiple seasons or was cancelled , these supernatural series showcase the creativity and diversity within the genre. I encourage you to explore these shows regardless of their current
Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them—at no extra cost to you. This helps support my blog, so thank you for your support!
